Thursday Night Conversations
On Thursday evenings, the men gathered at All Saints’ Episcopal Church, in the low, golden light that leaked through frosted windows and onto the folding chairs arranged in a circle around a chipped oak coffee table. The coffee was always burnt. The folding chairs always sagged. And the conversation, each week, teetered between the Book of Matthew and mortgage rates. That evening, however, a peculiar hush fell over the fellowship hall. Paul Hodges, who managed a used appliance store on Route 27 and had recently begun coloring his hair an indecisive shade of brown, arrived early. His fellow supplicant, Raymond Cullinan, a retired school superintendent with a plump figure and a usually withdrawn demeanor, arrived just behind him. The others were late. It was Paul who noticed the magazine first—left half-tucked beneath the pulpit ledger on the prayer table, beside a loose stack of missal photocopies and a half-eaten pear. The cover was garish and glossy, a throwback to something distinct...